Welcome, Guest
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username
  

Password
  





Search Forums

(Advanced Search)

Forum Statistics
» Members: 344
» Latest member: Brother Nathanael
» Forum threads: 8,659
» Forum posts: 15,619

Full Statistics

Online Users
There are currently 295 online users.
» 0 Member(s) | 291 Guest(s)
Applebot, Baidu, Bing, Google

Latest Threads
Fr. Hewko's Sermons: 25th...
Forum: November 2026
Last Post: Deus Vult
4 hours ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 130
Commentaries on the Bible...
Forum: Resources Online
Last Post: Stone
6 hours ago
» Replies: 0
» Views: 43
The Blessed Virgin in the...
Forum: Resources Online
Last Post: Stone
Yesterday, 09:42 AM
» Replies: 7
» Views: 641
Quo Primum is a forever b...
Forum: In Defense of Tradition
Last Post: Sheshallcrush
11-15-2026, 10:47 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 80
Posts on "Bishop" Pfeiffe...
Forum: "Bishop" Joseph Pfeiffer
Last Post: Stone
11-15-2026, 08:48 PM
» Replies: 2
» Views: 15,292
The Catholic Trumpet: The...
Forum: The Catholic Trumpet
Last Post: Stone
11-15-2026, 07:07 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 104
Twenty-fifth Sunday after...
Forum: Pentecost
Last Post: Stone
11-15-2026, 08:21 AM
» Replies: 3
» Views: 13,060
BULLETIN: XXV Sunday Afte...
Forum: Bulletin of the Oratory of the Sorrowful Heart of Mary
Last Post: Oratory
11-14-2026, 07:07 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 131
Defending Jerome’s SHE tr...
Forum: In Defense of Tradition
Last Post: Sheshallcrush
11-14-2026, 04:43 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 91
Christ figure destroyed a...
Forum: Anti-Catholic Violence
Last Post: Stone
11-14-2026, 04:31 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 118

 
  Commentaries on the Bible — Cornelius a Lapide - PDF
Posted by: Stone - 6 hours ago - Forum: Resources Online - No Replies

Print this item

  Quo Primum is a forever binding document
Posted by: Sheshallcrush - 11-15-2026, 10:47 PM - Forum: In Defense of Tradition - No Replies

The true Mass and the eternally binding document Quo Primum

Disclaimer: This post is my personal opinion and you must do your own research to verify the information contained within this post.

Imagine a Catholic who had spent his entire life going to a traditional Latin Mass.
Then, within a few years after Vatican 2, the sanctuary was rearranged. The priest would face the people. Latin would disappear. Gregorian chant disappears. The old altar was removed or relegated to the side. The priest might speak conversationally and no longer reverently. Lay people might come forward for various liturgical functions. Hymns that sounded more like popular music could replace traditional sacred music. The atmosphere of silence could be replaced by constant verbal interaction. The priest says the sacred canon in a loud voice. 
And then, in some parishes, things became considerably worse.


There were liturgical experiments involving folk music, guitars, drums, dancing, theatrical presentations, informal vesture, unusual offertory practices, balloons, children's performances, and other gimmicks. The term “clown Mass” became associated with the Novus Ordo. Many Catholics would leave the church or not go to Mass anymore. Husbands and fathers would no longer want to lead their families to Mass when there is zero reverence and a complete lack of masculinity from the priest. 


There is the false notion many Catholics have that the New Order Mass is just a simple translation of the traditional Latin rite, with a few small changes here and there. This is not true. It is a re-write, and quite substantial one, undertaken by a commission set up by Paul VI to implement the Council’s teaching on the liturgy. 

The head of this commission was a man named Archbishop Anibale Bugnini. This man was suspect  to being a freemason. Many modernists in the Vatican knew this all along but once word got out, they were forced to exile Bugnini to Iran. So essentially the main architect of the Novus Ordo mass was a Freemason thus making it a modernist-Masonic ceremony. Bugnini also brought six Protestant “experts” to the commission in order to help design the new mass. These “experts” would destroy the ancient Roman Rite given to us by St. Peter and safeguarded by St. Pope Clement in 88 AD. By the time of Pope Gregory the Great the canon of the Mass and prayers were fixed. From that moment it was basically unchanged for nearly 1,400 years until Vatican 2. The traditional worship handed down by Our Lord and His apostles was replaced with a new Protestant-Masonic style worship called the Novus Ordo.


Eugene Brand, one of the Lutheran representatives at this commission, later publicly boasted, “We have finished the work that Martin Luther began.” And Fr. Bugnini stated that his aim in designing the New Mass was “to strip from our Catholic prayers and from the Catholic liturgy everything which can be the shadow of a stumbling block for our separated brethren, that is, for the Protestants.” 

Jean Guiton, an observer at Vatican 2 stated, “The goal of Paul VI was to make the Catholic Mass look closer to a Calvinist mass.” 

Why are we making the mass more appealing to Protestants? Why are we inviting Protestant “experts” to give us advice on how to run our Mass? Why are we destroying a 2000 year old ancient Latin rite?

The designers of the New Mass have boasted endlessly on the novelty and revolutionary nature of their creation, and you can find many examples. I will give one here: Fr. Joseph Gelineau, SJ, one of the Catholic “experts” involved in its formulation, stated: “This needs to be said without ambiguity: the Roman Rite as we knew it no longer exists. It has been destroyed." 

Modernist Paul VI stated: 
“The introduction of the vernacular will certainly be a great sacrifice for those who know the beauty, the power and the expressive sacrality of Latin. We are parting with the speech of the Christian centuries, we are becoming like profane intruders in the literary preserve of sacred utterance. We will lose a great part of that stupendous and incomparable artistic and spiritual thing, Gregorian chant.” -Pope Paul VI

Compare this with St. Pope Pius X: “The language proper to the Roman church is Latin. Hence it is forbidden to sing anything whatever in the vernacular in solemn liturgical functions-much more to sing in the vernacular the variable or common parts of the mass and office.” 

And Pope Pius XII:

“The day the Church abandons her universal tongue [Latin] is the day before she returns to the catacombs." -Pope Pius XII


The Council of Trent says that it is forbidden to create a new experimental rite for the Roman Church:

"If anyone says that the received and approved rites of the Catholic Church... may be changed by any pastor of the Churches whomsoever to any new ones: let him be anathema."
[Canon 13 on the Sacraments, Session VII, March 3, 1547]

St. Pope Pius V canonized the Latin Mass in his binding document Quo Primum: 

“Let all everywhere adopt and observe what has been handed down by the Holy Roman Church, the Mother and Teacher of the other churches, and let Masses not be sung or read according to any other formula than that of this Missal published by us.” Quo Primum, St. Pope Pius V

“Would anyone, however, presume to commit such an act [infringe on this decree], he should know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul.” -Quo Primum, St. Pope Pius V

Canon lawyer and doctor in Thomistic theology Fr Hesse explains why Quo Primum is a forever binding document. 
“The law that has to be prayed (lex orandi) determines the law that has to be believed (lex credendi). For example, in early times of Christianity the immaculate conception was the law that had to be prayed. There was even a specific day set during the year to venerate Mary and the immaculate conception; but, it was not the law that had to be believed until Pope Pius IX defined it in the 19th century. Now no Pope can ever take this back. It is forever binding. The Tridentine Mass was the law that had to be prayed, codified by the council of Trent. After the council of Trent, Saint Pope Pius V created a papal bull called Quo Primum in which he defined that the Tridentine Mass was the law that had to be believed. Therefore, the Tridentine Mass is the official Mass of the Roman Church and no one can ever change this. This is forever binding and no Pope can change this.”


The argument is that the Mass should not be understood as merely a disciplinary regulation that a pope may freely redesign according to changing pastoral preferences, but as the Church’s lex orandi—the law of prayer through which the faith itself is expressed and handed down. In this view, the principle lex orandi, lex credendi means that what the Church worships publicly is intimately connected to what she believes doctrinally: the liturgy is therefore not simply a set of external rules but is the core expression of the Catholic faith. This is the reasoning behind the claim that Quo Primum carried a significance extending beyond ordinary liturgical legislation. When St. Pius V promulgated the Roman Missal in 1570, he sought to establish a unified Roman rite and used exceptionally strong language concerning its perpetual use. The popes who followed him did not treat this as an ordinary or disciplinary law that could simply be discarded at will. Instead, subsequent popes made revisions within the Roman Missal rather than repudiating its fundamental form: they added saints' feasts, adjusted calendars, clarified rubrics, and made limited modifications while retaining the essential structure and the Roman Canon. Even when genuine changes were made, they were presented as revisions of the received Roman Missal rather than the creation of an entirely new liturgical system. 


Some “conservatives” from the Novus Ordo argue that St. Pope Pius V never intended to bind his successors because he edited the Missal right after he published it. This is a faulty argument. St. Pope Pius V never actually changed the Missal, he simply clarified some things that were unclear. The 1570 Missal was the initial edition, and there were multiple printings almost immediately afterward. The early printings contained typographical and textual corrections. The first edition itself had some corrections made during printing, and further corrections appeared in the 1571 printings. Pius V added the feast of Our Lady of Victory in 1571, following the Christian victory at Lepanto. His successor Gregory XIII subsequently changed the name of that feast to the Feast of the Most Holy Rosary. We clearly see that fixing typographical errors or adding feast days for saints does not contradict Quo Primum. Changing the essential structure of the mass to be something entirely different is what contradicts Quo Primum. From the Council of Trent to 1962 no Pope ever dared to change or alter the Roman Missal. When Popes after Pius V would make revisions to add feast days they would always add their name after Pius V in the missal. They kept the name of Pius V because they wanted to make clear that they are respecting Quo Primum and are working within it. Keeping the name of Pius V is unusual because normally Popes cancel out their predecessors' names when they make a revision. Clearly the Popes have understood Quo Primum to be binding on them. John XXIII and Paul VI were the first that dared to go against Quo Primum. The Tridentine Mass is the only Mass of the Roman Catholic Church.


Father David Hewko states: 

“The Mass codified by St. Pope Pius V is like a perfectly cut diamond. One more cut or modification will ruin the whole thing. This is why Saint Pius V made the Tridentine Mass the true Mass to last until the end of time.” (Sermon August 2020 SSPX Marian Corps)


The traditionalist argument reaches its strongest point when contrasted with the reform promulgated by Paul VI. His own apostolic constitution explicitly acknowledges that the reform involved a revision of the Ordo Missae, a substantially enlarged lectionary, changes to the rites of the Mass, and, most significantly, the addition of three new Eucharistic Prayers alongside the Roman Canon. It also states that portions of the offertory, the breaking of the bread, and Communion rites were simplified or altered. From this perspective, the concern is theological as much as disciplinary: if the traditional Roman Mass had served for centuries as the Church's authoritative expression of Eucharistic sacrifice, priesthood, worship, and Catholic belief, then substantially replacing its prayers and ritual structure necessarily raises the question of whether something more profound than a disciplinary adjustment has occurred. The case, therefore, is that the Mass is not merely a rulebook for how Catholics happen to worship; it is one of the principal ways the Catholic faith is confessed, transmitted, and embodied.


During the promulgation of the new mass, traditionalist Cardinal Ottaviani and Bacci wrote a critical study of the new mass. They were helped by theologians Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and Bishop De Laurier. This was called the Ottaviani intervention. Here is what they said:

“…the Novus Ordo represents, both as a whole and in its details, a striking departure from the Catholic theology of the Mass as it was formulated in Session XXIII of the Council of Trent...It is evident that the Novus Ordo has no intention of presenting the Faith as taught by the Council of Trent, to which, nonetheless, the Catholic conscience is bound forever…” -Ottaviani Intervention (A study of the Novus Ordo mass)

Vatican 2 is similar to the heretical council of Pistoia condemned by Pope Pius VI (not to be confused with Paul VI). This was a council created by bishops who had modernist and Jansenist beliefs. Pope Pius VI condemned its teachings in Auctorem fidei (1794 AD), judging 85 propositions from the synod to be erroneous, heretical, schismatic, or otherwise dangerous because they undermined established Catholic doctrine and, particularly, the the Church's received tradition and liturgy. 


Pope Pius VI 1794 AD exposes the clever strategy these innovators use to introduce error and heresy: Ambiguities.

"They knew the capacity of innovators in the art of deception. In order not to shock the ears of Catholics, the innovators sought to hide the subtleties (errors) of their tortuous maneuvers by the use of seemingly innocuous words (ambiguities) such as would allow them to insinuate error into souls in the most gentle manner. Once the truth had been compromised, they could, by means of slight changes or additions in phraseology, distort the confession of the faith (the doctrine) that is necessary for our salvation, and lead the faithful by subtle errors to their eternal damnation…” -Pope Pius VI’s Apostolic Constitution Auctorem Fidei against the Errors of the Synod of Pistoia- August, 28,1794

Compare this with the Vatican 2 innovators: 


"We have used ambiguous terms during the Council and we know how we shall interpret them afterwards." -Fr. Edward Schillebeeckx, consultant at the Second Vatican “Council”


“The Church has peacefully undergone its October Revolution” Fr. Yves Congar, referring to Vatican II

Further, Pope Pius VI when he condemned the heretical council of Pistoia, also condemned the new mass 175 years before it was created.

33. “The proposition of the synod by which it shows itself eager to remove the cause through which, in part, there has been induced a forget-fulness of the principles relating to the order of the liturgy, "by recalling it (the liturgy) to a greater simplicity of rites, by expressing it in the vernacular language, by uttering it in a loud voice" as if the present order of the liturgy, received and approved by the Church, had emanated in some part from the forgetfulness of the principles by which it should be regulated…” Pope Pius VI calls this: “RASH, OFFENSIVE TO PIOUS EARS, INSULTING TO THE CHURCH, FAVORABLE TO THE CHARGES OF HERETICS AGAINST IT.”


Here is a snap shot of the changes to the Novus Ordo Mass: 

  1. The prayers at the foot of the altar and ancient offertory prayers have been replaced by downplaying sacrificial language. They now resemble a Jewish table blessing.
  2. The last gospel was removed.
  3. The universal Language Latin was taken away and vernacular introduced.
  4. Communion in the hand leading to careless abuses.
  5. Communion under both bread and wine instead of bread alone. This makes people see it as a symbol instead of the true transubstantiation taking place with flesh and blood in the host.
  6. Female altar-servers serving at the altar during Mass with the priest.
  7. Lay people handing out communion even though their hands are not anointed.
  8. 16 genuflections reduced down to only 3.
  9. More focus on scripture readings and reduction of ritual gives a protestantized tone.
  10. Priest facing the people instead of God at the altar implies man is the priority and not God.
  11. Altars removed and replaced with a table for a communal meal similar to Protestant churches.
  12. Communion rails torn out because no need to kneel for Blessed Sacrament anymore.


If St. Robert Bellarmine were alive today he would condemn the new Mass: 
St. Robert Bellarmine said:  "When we enter ornate and clean Basilicas, adorned with crosses, sacred images, altars and burning lamps, we most easily conceive devotion.  But on the other hand, when we enter the temples of the heretics, where there is nothing except a chair for preaching and a table for making a meal, we feel ourselves to be entering a profane hall and not the House of God."

Print this item

  The Catholic Trumpet: They Hate the Catholic Resistance Most...
Posted by: Stone - 11-15-2026, 07:07 PM - Forum: The Catholic Trumpet - No Replies

Print this item

  Fr. Hewko's Sermons: 25th Sun. After Pentecost/“St. Albert the Great”  11/15/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - 11-14-2026, 10:24 PM - Forum: November 2026 - Replies (1)

Twenty Fifth Sun. After Pentecost (6th Epiphany)
with Commemoration of “St. Albert the Great” 
November 15, 2026 (PA)




Audio

Print this item

  BULLETIN: XXV Sunday After Pentecost
Posted by: Oratory - 11-14-2026, 07:07 PM - Forum: Bulletin of the Oratory of the Sorrowful Heart of Mary - No Replies

[Image: 20220221190236_f69491cd89bdf4116d1c990c1...14bec.webp]

Print this item

  Defending Jerome’s SHE translation of Gen 3:15
Posted by: Sheshallcrush - 11-14-2026, 04:43 PM - Forum: In Defense of Tradition - No Replies

The following post is my opinion on the pronoun question of Genesis 3:15. Many of you may be aware by now that the Vatican 2 new religion rejects Mary’s role in crushing the serpent. After the second Vatican “council” the modernists created a new vulgate that contradicts the infallible Latin Vulgate of St. Jerome. This “new vulgate” translates Genesis 3:15 to say “it shall crush thy head” becoming nearly identical to the Protestant King James Version. Modern “Catholic” bibles such as the RSV-CE say “he shall crush thy head.” However, the translation used throughout all of Christian history up until the Protestant revolution was “SHE shall crush thy head.” Why is there a disagreement on the pronoun you might ask? 

The short answer is the original Hebrew and Greek texts had the SHE tradition but Jewish scribes over time changed it to “he/it.” Over time the original “she” manuscripts became a rare minority and the “he/it” manuscripts became dominant. I can prove that “she” was the original tradition, contrary to what modern scholars think. It is important for all traditional Catholics to learn and spread the information I am about to provide. 

If you do an online search on the pronoun debate of Genesis 3:15 modern sources will say the Hebrew says “he”. This is false and misleading. The majority of masoretic manuscripts from the 9th-12th century AD say “he” but they are 1000 years after Christ. They are NOT the original Hebrew stream. St. Jerome’s vulgate was written 390 AD using Hebrew and Greek texts from the Caesarea library that likely trace to +300 BC (which I will show later). Jerome used pre Masoretic texts. 

It is also important to note that the Masoretic Hebrew from the Middle Ages added vowel pointing that was NOT originally present in the ancient stream. They use an entirely new system of the Hebrew language that looks nothing like the ancient Hebrew language. For example, in the Dead Sea scrolls (250 BC) the pronoun for “he” and “she” looked identical. It won’t allow me to paste it here but I will describe it. The pronoun for “he” and “she” both contained a “waw” in the ancient Hebrew. There are numerous sections of the Old Testament where “she” had a waw and the Masoretes would put a feminine vowel pointing to it in the Middle Ages. However, without the vowel point you literally could not tell if a pronoun said “he” or “she” in the originals. Because you could not know it visually speaking, you only knew through the vocal tradition of the Jewish leaders and doctors. A good point against sola scriptura because you need the vocal tradition in order to correctly interpret the text. So to summarize this paragraph the original Hebrew manuscripts showed an epicene and completely visually ambiguous pronoun that could only be known through vocal tradition. Roughly 1000 years after Christ, Jewish scribes started adding masculine or feminine vowel points to these ambiguous pronouns in order to make them visually clear. However, these Jews from the Middle Ages don’t know the original vocal tradition and were making changes based on their own private interpretation. They essentially corrupted the text with their opinions. 

While most medieval scribes put a masculine vowel point, I have found multiple Hebrew  outside the Masoretic that have a feminine vowel point, indicating an older stream. These include Fr. Francis Xavier Patrizi who located 3 Hebrew texts that say “she shall crush thy head” marked by scribes as explicitly feminine. Bernard De Rossi located a Hebrew and Aramaic text in the De Rossi library that says “she.” Benjamin Kennicott located 2 Hebrew texts that say “she” (modern scholars try to disprove this one by looking at a mis-numbered online source. Dont listen to them). Also, the 1572 Polyglot uses an ancient Spanish Sephardic manuscript that says “she” with feminine vowel points. 

How do we know these feminine manuscripts reflect the original stream? 

While some manuscripts say “she” and others “he”, one thing they all have in common is that the verb “to crush” is masculine. A feminine pronoun SHE with a masculine verb “to crush” attached is evidence of antiquity not an argument against it. The original Hebrew Old Testament was full of gender discord and grammatical irregularities. It wasn’t as strict as modern Hebrew. We see feminine subjects with masculine verbs in places like Song of Songs 5. 

Here is the check mate: 

A principle in textual criticism is LECTIO DIFFICILIOR POTIOR (the more difficult reading is stronger). It essentially states when two manuscripts are competing, the one that is more grammatically irregular is more likely to be the original. This proves SHE is the original. No scribe would ever create a grammatically awkward construction on their own. It had to be original. Any scribe coming across the original vocal tradition of SHE would’ve had a strong motivation to switch the pronoun to HE so that it matches the masculine verb “to crush”. The scribes had a motivation to smooth out the awkward original text. They essentially ruined it by thinking they were “fixing” it. This is how SHE became rare and HE/IT became dominant. 

Additionally, there is a feminine Greek Septuagint tradition (likely 300 BC) found by Benedictine scholar Bernard Montfaucon. It was identified in Origen’s time and came from an ancient unknown author. It was stored in the Caesarea library that St. Jerome frequently utilized for his SHE translation. Unfortunately, the library was burned by a fire by the Muslims in the 7th century. Montfaucon published surviving fragments. An Ancient Greek text would have directly copied from the original Hebrew tradition. The original Hebrew and Greek said “she shall crush thy head.” Modern Hebrew and Greek have false translations. 

Also, don’t let anyone tell you Jerome never wrote “she.” The Vetus Latina (predates the vulgate) says ipsa SHE. Jerome was convinced by the church fathers of the authenticity of these feminine manuscripts. SHE certainly did not come from the Middle Ages. Also, Philo of Alexandria first century BC believed SHE is more logical than he. The enmity is between the woman and the serpent. Not between her seed and the serpent. 

Both Mary and Jesus crush the serpent but Mary is the one with the direct enmity against the serpent. Mary and Jesus are not competitors but are totally linked as Woman and her seed. Think of a female sniper who has the serpent’s head in her cross hairs. She fires the bullet perfectly striking him in the head. Jesus is the bullet but Mary pulled the trigger. Her perfect fiat and full of grace humiliated the serpent and crushed his head. 

Let us reject the false second Vatican “council” and all of its heresies. 

Our Lady, Co-Redemptrix pray for us.

Print this item

  Christ figure destroyed amid growing hatred of the sacred
Posted by: Stone - 11-14-2026, 04:31 PM - Forum: Anti-Catholic Violence - No Replies

From disclose.tv, November 14, 2026:


Christ figure destroyed amid growing hatred of the sacred

[Image: Sakrileg.png]


A statue of Christ was destroyed on November 11 in the courtyard of the Shrine of Divine Mercy in Vilnius, Lithuania. Police are investigating the incident as a public order disturbance.

Video shows a man posing with the gold-colored figure after removing it from a cross, while another man takes his picture. The two fled when the statue broke. The suspect had been identified as a "drunk Brit tourist."

OIDAC Europe recorded 94 arson attacks on churches and other Christian sites in 2024, nearly twice the previous year’s total.

Print this item

  Oratory Conference: Did Abp. Lefebvre Call Religious Liberty 'Very Limited'? 11/12/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - 11-14-2026, 12:11 PM - Forum: History - No Replies

"Did Abp. Lefebvre Call Religious Liberty 'Very Limited'?"
November 12, 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  Oratory Conference: Sacred Liturgy: Pre-Vatican II Groundwork for Revolution 11/12/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - 11-14-2026, 12:07 PM - Forum: Liturgical Studies - No Replies

Sacred Liturgy: "Pre-Vatican II Groundwork for Revolution"
November 12, 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  Oratory Conference: Leviticus Ch. 11 "Wise Advice From Young Bp. Williamson" 11/12/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - 11-14-2026, 12:02 PM - Forum: Sacred Scripture - No Replies

Leviticus: Ch. 11 "Wise Advice From Young Bp. Williamson" 
November 12, 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  St. Francis of Sales: One Should Speak Freely Against Heretics and Schismatics
Posted by: Stone - 11-14-2026, 08:59 AM - Forum: Church Doctrine & Teaching - No Replies

One Should Speak Freely Against Heretics and Schismatics


False ecumenism, so widespread and common in our days and coming from high ecclesiastical authorities, affirms that is not charitable to condemn heretics, schismatics, and other enemies of the Catholic Church.

To stop attacking these people is falsely presented as an act of love, and a obligation of Catholics. The truth, however, is the opposite as one can read
in the Saints and Doctors of the Church.

We transcribe below a text of St. Francis of Sales, Doctor of the Church, universally known for his goodness and charity. He strongly advises us to condemn the enemies of the Church:
Quote:The declared enemies of God and His Church, heretics and schismatics, must be criticized as much as possible, as long as truth is not denied.

It is a work of charity to shout: "Here is the wolf!" when it enters the flock or anywhere else.


(Introduction to the Devout Life, part III, chap. 29)

Print this item

  St. Thomas Aquinas: Whether Heretics Should Be Tolerated
Posted by: Stone - 11-14-2026, 08:37 AM - Forum: Doctors of the Church - No Replies

The Young St. Thomas on Tolerating Heretics

" [...] we are pleased to offer today a translation, courtesy of www.theaquinasinstitute.org, of a fine article in St. Thomas’s Scriptum super Sententiarum Petri Lombardi, Bk. 3, dist. 13, qu. 2, art. 3: “Whether heretics should be tolerated.”

Readers familiar with his treatment of this question in the Summa (II-II, q. 10, a. 8, ad 1; q. 11, a. 3) will see many of the same points made, but here we have them fresh from the Master of the Sacred Page writing his doctoral dissertation."


Whether Heretics Should Be Tolerated
[Sustinendi]
(Scriptum super Sent. IV.13.2.3)

[Image: ?u=https%3A%2F%2Ftse1.mm.bing.net%2Fth%3...3D15.1&f=1]


Objection 1. It seems that heretics should be tolerated. For nothing should be attacked except what is against friendship. But a difference of opinions is not against the harmony of friendship, as the Philosopher implies in Ethics 9. Therefore, they are not to be attacked.

Objection 2. Furthermore, what is necessary is not to be impeded. But heresy is necessary to the Church: it is necessary for heresies to exist, so that those who are tested may be made manifest (1 Cor 11:19). Therefore they are not to be attacked.

Objection 3. Furthermore, the Lord commanded that weeds be permitted to grow until harvest (cf. Mt 13:30). But the harvest is the end of the ages. Therefore since heretics are weeds, it seems that they must be permitted to grow until the end of the world.

Objection 4. Furthermore, no wise man should nod at what cannot ensue. But, as it says in a certain gloss on Isaiah 7, as long as the world stands, wise speech, secular speech, and heretical speech will dominate. Therefore the Church should not nod at the persecution of heretics.

Objection 5. Furthermore, no one believes without willing, as Augustine says. But heretics err in their faith. Therefore they are not to be forced.


Sed contra 1. But to the contrary, the Apostle commands that the old ferment be uprooted for it corrupts the whole mass (cf. 1 Cor 5:6-7). But heretics corrupt the Church the most. Therefore they are to be rooted out of the Church.

Sed contra 2. Furthermore, wolves are to be defended against by the office of pastors, as is clear from John 10:12. But heretics are wolves, as is clear in Acts 20:29.

Sed contra 3. Furthermore, spiritual life is better than physical. But murderers are rooted out because they take men’s physical lives. Therefore, much more should heretics be, who take men’s spiritual lives.


Response: I answer that heresy infects with vices; hence it says they lead much toward ungodliness, and their speech spreads like a cancer (2 Tim 2:16-17). And so the Church excludes them from the company of the faithful, and particularly those who corrupt others, so that the simple, who can be easily corrupted, are segregated from them not only in mind, but also physically. And this is why they are imprisoned and expelled by the Church. Now, if they did not corrupt others, they could also be concealed. But those who are firm in the faith can spend time with them physically so that they might convert them; nevertheless they cannot share in divine things, for they are excommunicated. But in secular judgment, they can licitly be killed, and despoiled of their goods, even if they do not corrupt others, for they are blaspheming against God, and they keep a false faith. And so they can be justly punished more than those who are guilty of the crime of offending majesty and those who forge false money.


Reply to Objection 1: The Philosopher is speaking only of speculative opinions. But consensus in the unity of the faith is the principle of communion in charity; and therefore dissent in the faith excludes the friendship of familiarity.

Reply to Objection 2: Heresy is said to be necessary not speaking per se, but incidentally, inasmuch as God draws something good out of any evil. For according to Augustine, the Church uses heretics to prove its own faith, namely when it attacks their false dogmas.

Reply to Objection 3: The Lord commanded that the weeds not be rooted out for this reason: lest perhaps the wheat should be uprooted at the same time with them. And so, this approach has a place among those about whom it is not clear whether or not they are heretics.

Reply to Objection 4: Although the Church cannot make it so that there are no heretics, nevertheless it can force this or that one individually; just as also we cannot avoid all venial sins, but we can strive to avoid individual ones.

Reply to Objection 5: The Church does not prosecute them so that they may be led to believe by violence, but so that they may not corrupt others, and lest so great a sin remain unpunished.

Adapted from here.

Print this item

  Oratory Conference: Immortale Dei (Cont'd) Leo XIII "Opinions vs. Doctrine" 11/12/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - 11-13-2026, 12:29 PM - Forum: Popes & Encyclicals - No Replies

"Immortale Dei" (Cont'd) Leo XIII "Opinions vs. Doctrine"
November 12, 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  Oratory Conference: Apologetics: "Christ Founded His Church & 7 Sacraments" 11/11/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - 11-13-2026, 12:24 PM - Forum: Apologetics - No Replies

Apologetics: "Christ Founded His Church & 7 Sacraments"
 November 11, 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  Liberalism Is the Most Dangerous Enemy of the Social Reign of Christ
Posted by: Stone - 11-13-2026, 11:16 AM - Forum: Resources Online - No Replies

Liberalism Is the Most Dangerous Enemy of the Social Reign of Christ
Fr. Henri Ramière
Le Règne Social du Coeur de Jesus, Toulouse, France, 1832, chapter "Dangers of Catholic Liberalism"


TIA | July 23, 2018

The French Jesuit Fr. Henri Ramière (1821-1884) was a renowned theologian, philosopher, historian, writer and great apostle of the devotion to the Sacred Heart of Jesus; he founded a monthly magazine Messenger of the Heart of Jesus and edited it until the end of his life.

[Image: 010_Ram.jpg]

Fr. Henri Ramière (1821-1884)

At Vatican Council I, he was a strong opponent of the Liberalism he saw entering the Church and society. Pope Pius IX congratulated this Jesuit for his work titled Church Teaching on Liberalism (Les Doctrines Romaines sur le Libéralisme). In 1871 the same Pope entrusted him with the task of writing to all the Catholic Bishops commanding them to promote the consecration of the Christian world to the Sacred Heart of Jesus.

To demonstrate how the tenets of Liberalism that Fr. Ramière warned against have become common thinking among Catholics, today under the title of Progressivism, TIA transcribes here a very opportune chapter of his outstanding work, The Social Reign of the Heart of Jesus (Le Règne Social du Coeur de Jesus), published in Toulouse, France.

This chapter was also published twice as an article in his monthly Messenger in September 1868 and in 1871 under the title "Dangers of Catholic Liberalism."


+ + +


In the world there was an army whose history, through 18 centuries, was an uninterrupted series of apparent reverses and real triumphs. Always fighting against enemies a hundred times more numerous, this army had conquered them all, and its flatterers assured it that it had annihilated them. Guard of a citadel of which God was the protector, it laughed at the assaults of the mighty on earth; and the futility of the efforts of the greatest conquerors to weaken it gave it the right to despise the future attacks it would face.

But, behold, the enemy, unable to overcome this army by force, resorted to an infernal stratagem: He addressed himself to the defenders of the citadel and entrusted to them the charge of demolishing the fortifications and opening the gates. However, in order to gain their consent, he did not foolishly propose to them such a betrayal, which the loyal spirits of that army’s warriors would have rejected.

[Image: 010_fortress.jpg]

A citadel that for centuries triumphed over all the assaults of the enemy

The enemy’s craft had more skill: He appealed to the warriors' generosity; he persuaded them that if they had the right to defend the citadel, their adversaries had an equal right to attack it. Therefore, justice required that, instead of expending all their forces to reject these attacks, they should defend the rights of the assailants.

The maneuver, unfortunately, had an effect: Inside that powerful army, which unity had made invincible, a numerous party formed that took as a war cry "the freedom to attack!" Those who did not want to enlist in this party found themselves, on the part of their brothers-in-arms, the target of a hostility more acerbic than that of the enemies. This hostility extended even to the Chief chosen by God to command this army. His own soldiers – regardless of the firmness that had maintained a strict discipline in the army, which until that day had been its strength – did not fear to contest the prerogative of his supreme authority.

There is not one of our readers who has not seen through the transparent veil of this allegory and applied it to the dangers to which Liberalism exposes the army of Jesus Christ. This is, in truth, the weeds sown by the enemy in the field of the head of a household. It is the trap by which so many noble hearts allowed themselves to be caught. It is the strategy that gave advantages to the immortal Adversary of Truth that violence did not give.

*

What, then, is Catholic Liberalism? It is a mitigated form of absolute Liberalism, or, in other words, free-thinking. It has always been the tactic of the Father of Lies to unite more moderate errors with extreme errors, thus to more readily seduce those who would be repelled by absolute denials of the Faith.

This is how in the 17th and 18th centuries Jansenism, a mitigated Lutheranism, dragged along many minds that would have repelled Luther's blasphemy. The free-thinkers are the Protestants of the 19th century and the legitimate descendants of Luther.

[Image: 010_circle.jpg]

The circle of so-called 'reformers' with Luther at the center who challenged the supremacy of truth

Luther protested against the supremacy of the Pope and against the authority of the Church; free-thinkers protest against the authority of Jesus Christ and the supremacy of truth. Luther claimed for every "Christian" the right to believe and teach what he thought he had found in the Bible; free-thinkers claim for every man the right to think and to maintain everything his reason invents.

The Protestants did not want any fixed dogma in the supernatural order; free-thinkers do not want any fixed principle in the rational order. In their view, there are only opinions and the public power has no right over these opinions; rather people should be given ever greater freedom to present and spread their personal opinions.

If someone wants to attack the existence of God, the soul, the future life and the most essential laws of morals, civil law should have no say in the matter. There is no crime to hold an opinion and, since thought is free, the word and the press must be equally so. Such is absolute Liberalism, which is also called Rationalism, the great dogmatic heresy of the 19th century.

Catholic Liberalism is far from reaching this point. It does not make the monstrous concessions to error that would destroy the integrity of the Faith. It does not deny that there is an absolute truth to which man must give the assent of his reason; it does not dispute the divinity of Jesus Christ and the authority of the Church; rather, it concurs with free-thinking in enclosing the faith in those truths that lie in the sphere of the individual conscience.

According to Catholic Liberalism with regard to society and the power that governs it, truth has no more rights than error. The public power should view those who hold both as merely having opinions whose freedom it is obliged to protect – as long as they do not resort to violence in order to obstruct the freedom of opposing opinions.

Thus, in the eyes of liberals, be they Catholic or anti-Catholic, the law must be atheistic, that is, it should not be concerned about God, as if He did not exist. For them, His precepts are non-existent, His authority is null and void, His Revelation worthless. In his intimate circles, as a Catholic and as a man, the magistrate can believe all this, but as a magistrate, in the exercise of his authority, he must behave absolutely as if he does not believe in anything.

The liberal theory requires, therefore, for all Catholics engaged in public office to have two consciences: a personal conscience, according to which all his personal actions conform to the law of God and a public conscience, which allows him to ignore any of these laws in the performance of his functions. As a Catholic, he hears Mass, and as a magistrate he assists at the laying of the cornerstone of a mosque. If we were still living in the time of Paganism, he would accompany Caesar to the temple of the idols.

We do not affirm that all Catholic liberals admit this theory in its full extension. To the contrary, we know that many refuse to bring to term the consequences of such principles; nonetheless, the consequence follows no less logically from the principles.

In fact, there is no middle ground: Either society is subject to God and then is obliged to defend His rights and to conform to His precepts, as Catholic doctrine prescribes; or society is independent of God and then has the absolute right not to be concerned about Him, which is legal Atheism.

The application of the two theories can suffer various modifications, but one theory absolutely excludes the other, and we must choose between them. If we defend, at least in theory, the supremacy of truth, we are Catholics; if we concede to error the same rights as truth, we are liberals.

For the anti-Catholic Liberalism this equality between truth and error is absolute; for the Catholic Liberalism it relates only to society and to the power that governs it. These are two different errors, but they agree in denying the rights of truth. In fact, even though this second form of Liberalism is much less repugnant than the first, it is no less opposed to Catholic doctrine and we do not exaggerate by qualifying it as heresy. For it is evident that it denies at the same time the rights of God, of Jesus Christ and of the Church.

Either God is nothing or He is the Sovereign Lord of all of societies as well as of individuals. To want to place Him outside of the law, to deny Him the essential authority, is to deny Him existence. Legislative Atheism necessarily leads to doctrinal Atheism.

Jesus Christ, no less than God His Father, has the right to the homage and the obedience of societies. When Christ came to earth, the Eternal Father gave to Him not only souls, but also the nations. He made Him Sovereign King and the only Savior of both peoples and individuals, applying the word of the Apostle: "For there is no other name under heaven given to men, whereby we must be saved." (Acts 4:12)

[Image: 010_King.jpg]

The truth of Christ must reign in both the temporal and religious spheres

By thus authorizing peoples to disregard the teachings and precepts of Jesus Christ in their collective existence, Liberalism violates the rights of the Heavenly Father as well as those of His Only Begotten Son.

In the same way Liberalism attacks the authority of the Church. In fact, she was made the sovereign depository of the Incarnate Word and the supreme interpreter of His law. Our Lord told the Apostles, "Go, therefore, and teach all nations, teaching them to observe all the things that I have commanded you." (Mt 28:19-20)

Here He makes no distinction between social and individual duties. He did not say to the Apostles, "Go and teach every man what he personally owes to God, but do not be concerned about what men assembled in a society owe to one another." He speaks not only to individuals, but to nations. When, therefore, Liberalism removes societies from the authority of the Church, leaving them to answer only to their individual consciences, with one stroke it reduces to nothing the institution of Our Lord Jesus Christ and the mission of the Church.

Yes, it reduces both to nothing, because the truth is one and indivisible. To want to divide truth into two parts, and then sacrifice one to the demands of the world in order to better maintain the other, is to destroy it entirely. We can be disposed to make excuses for the intentions of the Catholics who make this calculation, imagining that we are rendering a great service to the truth, but we are obliged to clearly tell them, with the Pope, that such a service rendered to the truth by its defenders is more harmful to it than the violent attacks of its enemies.

It is the judgment of Solomon – who ordered the baby of two women, who both claimed him, to be cut in half – applied in reverse, not on a mortal child, but on the immortal truth. The division, which for Solomon was just a sham, would ask liberal Catholics to do what is manifestly impossible. A man placed between his conscience, which is Catholic, and public opinion, which no longer is, and tries to save both cannot do so. To take up the sword and strike is to try to cut the truth into two pieces.

To public opinion he surrenders the social rights of this divine truth even as he preciously guards his individual rights for himself. How can he not see that the divine truth thus mutilated is no longer the truth and no longer has anything of the divine? If God no longer governs social relations, then He obviously does not deserve the homage of individuals. Ceding this point to free-thought, he thus surrenders it all; he hands over the citadel and sacrifices the crown of the Divine King, who he boasts to defend.

"But," as liberal Catholics say, "if we refuse this satisfaction to public opinion, it becomes irritated by us and we are unable to exert any influence over it."

Yes, this is true. Just as the Christians of the first centuries could not confess the unity of God and the divinity of Jesus Christ without raising the public opinion of their time against them, so also we cannot. It is always the same fight although the terrain is different. It is the secular battle against Jesus Christ.

To pretend to facilitate the salvation of the world by sacrificing the rights of the Savior would be to deceive ourselves with a foolish hope. Doing this, we would only make salvation impossible: first, because Jesus Christ would no longer be the true Savior if He were not the necessary Savior; second, because instead of conquering the affection of the world, we would only procure its contempt; third, because the truth would cease to have the power to save men should its defenders cease to assert it in all its integrity.

Indeed, it is not the attacks of the enemies that weaken the truth; these attacks, on the contrary, make it shine even brighter. Its very nature is to be combated by error, just as it is the nature of light to be opposed to darkness. So long as the truth is boldly, courageously and wholly asserted by those whom it chose to be its organs on earth, it retains all its power to enlighten minds of good faith.

But, if the organs charged with manifesting it to the world affirm it only half-way, how can obscure minds know it? What profit will error not draw in the fight from the imprudent concessions of its defenders?

Without a doubt, these mitigated errors, which seduce Catholics and even priests, are incomparably more disastrous to the truth than the extreme errors professed only by those who are openly impious. If the lamp that lights the house is hidden under the bushel, how can its inhabitants not stumble in the darkness? If the salt becomes tasteless, what is left to preserve the world from corruption?

Therefore, Pius IX did not exaggerate when he denounced Liberalism as a scourge more frightful to Catholic France than the violence of the tyrants of the Commune [the radically communist government that ruled Paris from March 19 to May 28, 1871). In so doing, he was not comparing the liberal Catholics to the leaders of the Commune. Rather, he likened the results of the illusion of the former to the consequences of the tyranny of the latter.

Print this item