Welcome, Guest
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username
  

Password
  





Search Forums

(Advanced Search)

Forum Statistics
» Members: 344
» Latest member: Brother Nathanael
» Forum threads: 8,672
» Forum posts: 15,651

Full Statistics

Online Users
There are currently 686 online users.
» 0 Member(s) | 679 Guest(s)
Applebot, Baidu, Bing, DuckDuckGo, Facebook, Google, Twitter

Latest Threads
The Blessed Virgin in the...
Forum: Resources Online
Last Post: Stone
8 hours ago
» Replies: 13
» Views: 1,076
St. Ambrose: The Order of...
Forum: Fathers of the Church
Last Post: Stone
8 hours ago
» Replies: 0
» Views: 56
Life of St. Cecilia by Do...
Forum: The Saints
Last Post: Stone
8 hours ago
» Replies: 11
» Views: 231
From Pachamama to Sachama...
Forum: Pope Leo XIV
Last Post: Stone
Yesterday, 06:59 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 72
Oratory Conference: "Shif...
Forum: Fr. Hewko's Sermons, Catechisms, & Conferences
Last Post: Deus Vult
Yesterday, 05:04 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 72
Oratory Conference: Apolo...
Forum: Apologetics
Last Post: Deus Vult
Yesterday, 04:50 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 66
Fr. Hewko's Sermons: + Re...
Forum: November 2026
Last Post: Deus Vult
Yesterday, 10:49 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 77
The Catholic Trumpet: Bi...
Forum: The Catholic Trumpet
Last Post: Stone
Yesterday, 08:17 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 86
Christ in Dachau by Fr. J...
Forum: Resources Online
Last Post: Stone
Yesterday, 07:55 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 76
St. Aelred: The Nature of...
Forum: Resources Online
Last Post: Stone
Yesterday, 07:36 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 78

 
  St. Ambrose: The Order of Melchisedech
Posted by: Stone - 8 hours ago - Forum: Fathers of the Church - No Replies

The Order of Melchisedech
A Sermon by St. Ambrose


THE CHRISTIAN Sacraments are older than the Jewish. You have come to the altar of God, you have seen the sacraments placed there, and you wonder to see there a created thing; nevertheless it is a solemn and an unusual created thing. Someone has said perhaps: God showed great favor to the Jews. He rained manna on them from heaven (Exod. xvi. 15). What more has He given His own faithful; what more has He given to those to whom He promised more?

Take in what I now say. The mysteries of the Christians were before those of the Jews; and more sacred are the sacraments of the Christians than those of the Jews. How can this be? Pay heed to this. Where did the Jews begin? From Judah, the great-grandson of Abraham; or, if you wish to understand it that way, from the Law; that is, when the Jews merited to receive the Law. So they are called Jews from the great-grandson of Abraham, or from the time of the saintly Moses. And if God then rained manna from heaven on the Jews, murmuring against Him, the figure of these holy sacraments preceded this: in Abraham's time, when he collected three hundred and eighteen well-appointed men, and pursued his enemies, and brought his grandchild back from captivity. Then, returning a victor, there met him Melchisedech the priest, and he offered bread and wine (Gen. xiv. 18).

Who had the bread and wine? Abraham did not have it. But who had it? Melchisedech. He then is the author of the sacraments (Heb. vii. 1 seq.). Who is Melchisedech? He who is made known to us as the King of Justice, the King of Peace. Who is the King of Justice? Can any man be King of Justice? Who then is King of Justice if not the Justice of God, Who is also the Peace of God, the Wisdom of God? Who could say: Peace I leave with you, my peace I give unto you? (Jn. xiv. 27.)

Let you then grasp, that these sacraments which you receive are prior in time to those of the Law of Moses; whatever the Jews may have to say. And that the Christian people had begun before the Jewish people had begun: we through predestination, they in name.

Melchisedech therefore offered a sacrifice of bread and wine. Who is Melchisedech? He was, says the Apostle, without father, without mother, without genealogy, having neither beginning of days nor end of life, but likened unto the Son of God, continueth a priest forever; and this we read in the Epistle to the Hebrews (vii). Without father, he says, and without mother. In this whom does he resemble? The Son of God. For the Son of God, in His heavenly generation, was born without a mother: He was born of the Father alone. And again when He was born of the Virgin, He was born without father: for He was not begotten of the seed of man, but born of the Holy Ghost (Mt. i. 20) and of the Virgin Mary, and brought forth from her virginal womb, in all things as the Son of God.

Melchisedech was also a priest, as Christ is a priest; to Whom it was said: Thou art a priest for ever according to the order of Melchisedech (Ps. cix. 4). Who therefore is the author of the sacraments if not the Lord Jesus? These sacraments have come down from heaven; from whence all counsel comes. It was a truly great and divine miracle that God should rain manna from heaven on His people; and that the people should eat though they did not work.

But perhaps you will say: My bread is ordinary bread. On the contrary, this bread is bread only before the words of the sacred rite. When the consecration has been added, from being bread it becomes the Body of Christ. Let us therefore prove this. How can that which is bread be the Body of Christ? By consecration. Consecration by what words; by whose words? Those of the Lord Jesus. For all the other words which are said previous to this are said by the priest: the praises that are offered to God, the prayer that is offered for the congregation, for rulers, and for others. But when the moment comes to consecrate the venerable sacrament, the priest will no longer use his own words, but will use the words of Christ. It is therefore the Word of Christ that consecrates this sacrament.

Who is the Word of Christ? Who but He by Whom all things were made. The Lord commanded, and the heavens were made. The Lord commanded, and the earth was made. The Lord commanded and the seas were made. The Lord commanded, and every creature was brought forth (Gen. i). You see then how wondrous in work is the Word of Christ.

If then there is such power in the Word of the Lord Jesus, so that the things that were not by It began to be, how much the more can It change what is into another thing? The heavens did not exist, nor the sea, nor the land, yet hearken to David speaking: He spoke, and they were made. He commanded, and they were created (Ps. cxlviii. 5). And accordingly I answer you; that the bread was not the Body of Christ before the consecration. But I say to you that after the consecration it is now Christ's Body. He spoke, and It was made. He commanded, and It was created. You were yourself; but you were your old self. After you were consecrated you began to be a new creature. Do you wish to know what sort of new creature? Everyone, says the Scripture, in Christ is a new creature (I Cor. v. 17).

Understand therefore how the words of Christ have changed every creature; and now change, when He wills, the order of nature. You wish to know in what manner? Listen then; and let us take an example from His own birth. It is the rule of nature that a man is born only from the conjugal relation of man and woman. But because the Lord willed it, because He chose this sacred means (sacramentum), Christ, that is, the one Mediator of God and men, the Man Jesus Christ (I. Tim. ii. 5), was born of the Holy Ghost, and the Virgin Mary. You see then how, contrary to the order and custom of nature, a Man was born of a Virgin?

Consider another example. The Jewish people were hemmed in by the Egyptians, and behind them was the sea. By divine command Moses struck the waters with a rod, and the waves divided; not certainly in accord with nature's laws, but in accord with the grace of the heavenly command (Exod. xiv). And consider another example. The people were thirsty, and they came upon a well. But it was a bitter well. So the saintly Moses cast a certain tree into the well, and the fountain that was bitter was made sweet; that is, it changed the quality of its nature, and was turned into sweetness (Exod xv. 23). Consider a fourth example. An iron axe had fallen into the water, and since it was iron it sank. And Elisaeus cast in a piece of wood, and the iron swam upon the surface of the water; and this purely is contrary to the nature of iron (IV Kgs. vi. 6), which is a far heavier element than water.

From these examples therefore you may understand how great is the power of the heavenly word. If it can work a wonder in an earthly well, if the heavenly word can work wonders in other things, will it not work similarly in the heavenly Sacraments? And so you have learned that the Body of Christ is made from bread; and that wine and water are mingled in the chalice, but that this becomes Blood by the consecration of the heavenly words. But perhaps you will say: 'I see no appearance of blood.' But it possesses a likeness to it. For as you have taken on the likeness of his death, so do you also drink the likeness of His Precious Blood: that there may be no horror of spilt blood, and yet that the price of our Redemption may be efficacious. You have therefore learned that what you receive is the Body of Christ.

THE WORDS of the Lord make and consecrate His own Body and Blood. And would you know by what heavenly words It is consecrated? Here then are the words. The Priest says: Grant us, he says, that this oblation may be attributed to us, confirmed, an offering of our reason, acceptable to Thee, as the figure of the Body and Blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, Who, on the day before He suffered took bread in His holy hands, looked up to heaven to Thee, Holy Father Almighty, Eternal God, and giving thanks, He blessed, broke it, and gave what was broken to His Apostles and to His Disciples, saying: Take ye, and eat ye all of this; for this is my body, which shall be broken for many (Lk. xxii. 19 V.I.)

In like manner also, on the day before He suffered, after He had supped, He took the chalice, looked up to heaven to Thee, Holy Father Almighty Eternal God, and giving thanks He blessed it and gave to His Apostles and Disciples, saying: Take ye and drink ye all of this; for this is my blood (Mt. xxvi. 27).

Consider all this. There are the words of the Evangelist up to Take ye, whether of the Body or the Blood. From there on they are the words of Christ: Take ye, and drink ye all of this; for this is my blood. Consider each word.

Who, he says, on the day before He suffered took bread in His holy hands. Before it is consecrated it is bread. When the words of consecration have been added, it is the Body of Christ. Then listen to Him saying Take ye, and eat ye all of this; for this is my body. Again, before the words of consecration, it is a chalice filled with wine and water. Where the words of Christ have wrought, there the Blood of Christ, Which has redeemed His people, is made. You see then in how many ways the words of Christ are able to change all things. Lastly, the Lord Jesus Himself testifies to us that we receive His Body and Blood. Are we to doubt His honesty and His testimony?

Now return with me to the main subject of my sermon. It was a great and venerable sign that manna rained from heaven upon the Hebrews (Exod. xvi. 13). But reflect. Which is the greater wonder: the manna from heaven, or the Body of Christ? The Body of Christ, the Creator of heaven. Then again he who ate manna is dead; but he that will eat of This Body his sins will be forgiven him, and he shall not die for ever.

So not without meaning do you say: Amen; in that moment confessing in spirit that you receive the Body of Christ. What the tongue confesses, let the heart hold fast.

That you may know that this is a divine mystery, its Figure preceded it. Learn then how great is this sacrament. Consider what He says: As often as you shall do this, do it in commemoration of Me, until I come again (cf. I Cor. xi. 26). And the Priest says: Mindful therefore of His most glorious passion, and of His Resurrection from the dead, and of His Ascension into heaven, we offer Thee this immaculate Host, this reasoning victim, this unbloody sacrifice, this holy Bread, and the Chalice of eternal life; and we beg and pray that by the hands of the Angels thou wilt receive this Offering upon Thy heavenly altar, as Thou didst deign to receive the gifts of Thy servant, Abel the Just, and the sacrifice of Abraham our father, and that which the High Priest Melchisedech offered to Thee.

So then, as often as you shall receive, what does the Apostle say to you? As often as you shall receive, you shall announce the death of the Lord. If we announce His death, we announce the forgiveness of sins. If as often as His Blood is shed, it is shed unto the remission of sins, I ought to receive It always; that my sins may always be forgiven. I who am always sinning ought always to have what heals me.

May the Lord our God preserve you in the grace He has given you, and may He deign to enlighten yet more the eyes He has opened, through His only Son, the Lord God our King and Savior, through Whom and with Whom be there to Him, together with the Holy Ghost, praise, honor, glory, magnificence, from all ages, and now, and for ever and ever, world without end.

Amen.

Print this item

  From Pachamama to Sachamama: Pagan hymn begins Leo XIV Peru Mass
Posted by: Stone - Yesterday, 06:59 PM - Forum: Pope Leo XIV - No Replies

From Pachamama to Sachamama: Pagan hymn begins Leo XIV Peru Mass
A Catholic priest composed the official welcome song for the Pope's Peruvian visit,
drawing on pagan influences after participating in indigenous shamanic rituals.

[Image: Untitled-19.png]

Pope Leo XIV walks after a meeting with faithful and representatives of popular devotion at Saqsaywaman National Archeological Park
 as part of an official visit to Peru on November 15, 2026, in Cusco, Peru
Photo by Raul Sifuentes/Getty Images


Thu Nov 19, 2026
(LifeSiteNews) — A Catholic priest composed a welcome hymn for a Mass celebrated by Pope Leo XIV during his recent Peru visit that explicitly invokes indigenous pagan spirits as “guardians” of nature and humanity.

On November 15, during the papal Mass at the regional sports complex in Pucallpa, Peru, an official welcoming song included explicit invocations of “Sachamamas,” indigenous pagan spirits venerated in Amazonian cosmology as the “mothers of the forest and water.”

Specifically, the lyrics declared: “Madres del monte y el agua / A jóvenes y ancianos cuidan / Para nuestro rostro no olvidar” (“Mothers of the forest and the water, care for the young and the old, so that our face may not be forgotten”).

The opening event took place at the regional sports complex known as “La Videnita” within the Apostolic Vicariate of Pucallpa, gathering thousands of attendees for the first papal Mass celebrated in the Peruvian Amazon. The hymn, titled “Greeting to Pope Leo XIV in Pucallpa,” was sung as the Holy Father entered the venue.

Composed by Father Segundo Gaviria Sandoval, a local Catholic priest, the song explicitly incorporates animistic Amazonian mythology alongside Christian language.

In an interview reported by Infobae.com, Sandoval confirmed that he directly participated in native shamanic rituals to compose the welcome hymn for Pope Leo XIV. The priest explained that he took part in “shamanic sessions with the shamans” across Amazonian tribes – including the Asháninkas, Shipibos, and Cocamas – stating: “I got myself invited to see, try, and experiment what the ayahuasca juice produces.”

Ayahuasca ceremonies are traditional shamanic rituals practiced among various indigenous peoples of the Amazon basin and later adopted by syncretic religious movements.

During these pagan rites, participants drink a beverage under the guidance of a shaman with the aim of entering altered states of consciousness, seeking healing, spiritual insight, visions, contact with spirits, or guidance from the supernatural world. Within Amazonian cosmology, these experiences are often interpreted as encounters with spiritual entities inhabiting nature.

The priest noted that while the drink only yielded “a clearer vision” and “more tranquility,” its main result was that he recorded in his “poor gray matter … the notes [and] the tones of the ícaros.”

Defining “ícaros” as “the invocation to the spirits, to God … for the healing of the sick,” Sandoval explained that upon learning of the Pontiff’s arrival, he spent “more than four months” adapting these spirit-invoking shamanic melodies to coordinate the music and rhymes of the official welcoming song performed at the papal Mass.

Ícaros are the chants sung during ayahuasca ceremonies, especially in the Peruvian Amazonian tradition. Shamans believe these songs are learned through spiritual revelation, visions, or instruction from plant spirits. Ícaros are also used to guide the ceremony, invoke spiritual forces, facilitate healing, protect participants from harmful influences, and direct the visionary experience induced by ayahuasca. Rather than functioning merely as music, they are traditionally understood as possessing a specific spiritual power and efficacy within the ritual itself.

The spirits mentioned in the song, “mothers of the forest and the water,” are known in Amazonian mythology as Sachamamas, a name that literally means “mothers of the forest” in the Quechua language. According to indigenous cosmology, Sachamamas are depicted as giant boas or serpents that dwell in and rule over the forests.

Print this item

  Oratory Conference: "Shift of Emphasis From Christ the King to the Mass" 11/18/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - Yesterday, 05:04 PM - Forum: Fr. Hewko's Sermons, Catechisms, & Conferences - No Replies

"Shift of Emphasis From Christ the King to the Mass" 
November 18, 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  Oratory Conference: Apologetics" "Did Christ Establish a Structured Church?" 11/18/26
Posted by: Deus Vult - Yesterday, 04:50 PM - Forum: Apologetics - No Replies

Apologetics" "Did Christ Establish a Structured Church?"
November 18, 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  Fr. Hewko's Sermons: + Requiem Mass + for Damien Oullet November 19, 2026
Posted by: Deus Vult - Yesterday, 10:49 AM - Forum: November 2026 - No Replies

+ Requiem Mass + for Damien Oullet 
November 19, 2026  (Ontario)

Print this item

  The Catholic Trumpet: Bishop Fellay, condemn this document once and for all!
Posted by: Stone - Yesterday, 08:17 AM - Forum: The Catholic Trumpet - No Replies

Bishop Fellay, condemn this document once and for all!

Print this item

  Christ in Dachau by Fr. John Lenz [Book Review]
Posted by: Stone - Yesterday, 07:55 AM - Forum: Resources Online - No Replies

Catholic Priests in a Concentration Camp

CHRIST IN DACHAU. By John M. Lenz (Roman Catholic Books, P.O. Box 2286, Fort Collins, Colo. 80522, 1960/2005 reprint), x + 328 pp.


Homiletic and Pastoral Review | April 1, 2009 by Book Reviews

Dachau is a small city of about 25,000 people in Bavaria, not far from Munich. A notorious concentration camp for so-called “enemies of the state” was built there by the Nazi government in 1933, the year Hitler took control. In 1957 while I was studying German near Munich in preparation for my theology studies in Innsbruck, an Austrian Jesuit seminarian offered to take me there to see the remains of the notorious death camp. [...]

Fr. John M. Lenz, the author of Christ in Dachau, was a prisoner there for six and a half years. The story he tells of priests living, dying and surviving in Dachau is very sobering and makes one think of the depths to which human beings can sink. For he describes the brutality of the place, the starvation, the cold, the slave labor, the beatings and executions, the thefts and the murders that were commonplace every day occurrences.

This book should be of special interest to priests because the Nazis gathered together all the priests from other camps and sent them to Dachau. While Fr. Lenz was there from 1939 to 1945 over 2,700 were interned there. Of that number he says that 1,034 died in the camp of starvation, disease, exhaustion or murder.

A special feature of the life in Dachau was the decision coming from Berlin as a result of the requests of the German Bishops and the Holy See that the priests be allowed to have a chapel. So Block 26 was set aside as a Catholic chapel. Through the talent of many of the priests, the chapel was decorated and made an island of beauty in the midst of supreme ugliness and despair. So from December 1941 until liberation in April 1945 the priests had Mass every day and they had the Blessed Sacrament reserved in the tabernacle made by one of the inmates. As the months went by vestments, chalices and so forth were sent to them and allowed into the camp. Thus the chapel became a powerhouse of prayer to sustain the priests in the midst of the suffering and brutality imposed on them by the godless Nazi system.

Fr. Lenz makes it clear that the Mass and the Blessed Sacrament gave strength to the priests to face each day with confidence in God’s mercy and providence. The priests in Dachau established a Christian community composed of men from twenty different countries and nationalities, all united as brothers in Christ. They exercised a very fruitful apostolate among the other inmates, bringing them Communion, hearing confessions, baptizing converts and anointing the dying. All of this had to be done secretly since religious activities in the camp were strictly forbidden and, if discovered, were punished severely.

The Nazis had a detailed plan to kill all the inmates and destroy the whole camp before it could be captured by the Americans, but the soldiers got there before the plan could be carried out. The soldiers found 1700 corpses stacked up waiting to be cremated or dumped into a mass grave.

Even though the book was published in 1960, and now has been reprinted, it is well worth reading. It reminds one of the gulags in Communist Russia, so graphically described by Solzhenitsyn and undoubtedly there are many similar camps in China, North Korea and Vietnam at the present time.

The title of this book, Christ in Dachau, refers to the fact that the vast majority of the priests interned in the camp lived their faith in trying circumstances and practiced Christian charity towards one another and towards their fellow inmates. The author, in describing man’s inhumanity to man, points out how faith in Jesus Christ is able to triumph over all suffering and adversity. Christ was present there in the minds and hearts of his priests and of the lay Catholics who lived and died there.

Because of the emphasis on the role of priests in Dachau the book is especially recommended for priests and seminarians. As an appendix there are 80 pictures of priests—some perished there and others survived to return to their priestly work for souls.

Kenneth Baker, S.J.
Ramsey, N.J.



See also: https://www.newoxfordreview.org/document...in-dachau/

Print this item

  St. Aelred: The Nature of True Friendship
Posted by: Stone - Yesterday, 07:36 AM - Forum: Resources Online - No Replies

The Nature of True Friendship

[Image: M021_SpiritualFriendship.jpg]

St. Aelred: the nature of true friendship


TIA | December 1, 2008

Is it possible for a Catholic to have a true friendship with a non-Catholic? My friend Jan asked this question recently because her daughter was insisting that friendship meant one person caring about another, and had nothing to do with sharing the same religion. Jan disagreed.

I am sure a modern dissertation on friendship would tend to agree with Jan’s daughter. But I do not put much stock in modern theories, which justify all kinds of abominations, e.g. homosexuality, cohabitation, contraception, abortion, euthanasia, feminism, and so on. The list is endless, and we are always instructed that we must be indulgent and tolerant should a “friend” adopt such positions, that a real friend accepts the person “as he is.”

Fueled by the ecumenical spirit of Vatican II, which counsels openness, dialogue and communion with persons of false religions and sects, more and more Catholics are adopting this position regarding friendship. Doctrine is not important. Only a charity based on feelings matters.

For my answer, let me turn to a traditional and much more secure source. In 1150, the English Abbot Aelred of Rievaulx, a Cistercian monastery in France, answered this question posed by a monk called Yves: What is true friendship? His answer is the famous treatise Spiritual Friendship, (1) three chapters written in a dialogue form that examines the relationship between friendship and the love of God.

The renowned Abbot’s sources are Scriptures, the writings of the Fathers – with St. Augustine a clear favorite – and great works of Antiquity such as Cicero’s De Amicitia [About Friendship]. Abbot Aelred’s credentials are the highest: In 1467 he was raised to the honor of the altars; his feast day is celebrated by the Cistercian Order on January 12.

Permit me to take the liberty of following the format of this beautiful treatise, formulating questions for you, my good friend Jan, with St. Aelred responding. There will be some adaptations: for example, in the 12th century when he lived there were no Protestants, so I will adapt some of his statements to our present day situation.


Is friendship with non-Catholics possible?

Jan: Is it possible for a Catholic to have true friendship with someone who is not Catholic?

St. Aelred: First, we must know what true friendship is. Let us take Cicero’s definition as a starting point: Friendship is agreement on matters human and divine with charity and good will (De Amicitia). This is only a starting point because we Catholics differ from the pagans in essential matters. The friendship that exists among us must begin in Christ, continue in Christ, and be perfected in Christ. True friendship cannot exist among those who live without Christ.(2)

You may argue that your Protestant friends accept Christ and, therefore, could be true friends. I believe not. Since harmony in thinking on “things divine” must exist among those who claim the illustrious name of friend, only those who share the full Catholic Faith can be accounted as true friends. Indeed, only by accepting the same dogmas can they be of one mind and avoid daily controversies and quarrels regarding faith. Further, one will support the other in the practice of virtue – with the aim of continuing the earthly friendship in Heaven.


Can one be friends with an impenitent sinner?

Jan: My daughter says she has “friends” who are homosexual. Is this possible?

St. Aelred: True friends must have a shared love of virtue. As far as he can, one friend tries to cure the defects he observes in the other. For the love of God, he may endure such defects with the aim of correcting them. But he can never approve - tacitly or explicitly - the vices or sins of another.

If a homosexual does not want to change his sinful situation, this principle applies to him: For he that loves iniquity does not love but hates his own soul (Ps. 10:6). So, he does not love his own soul and for that reason will never be capable of a true friendship. Further, those who affectionately approve each other’s vices are not real friends, but accomplices in the practice of evil. Their relationship is a distorted image of friendship that is not supported by truth. (3)

Regarding this relation that defiled persons profess for each other based on a likeness in evil, St. Alfred considered it unworthy of the name of friendship. (4)


Carnal and spiritual friendship

Jan: But it seems to me that something like friendship can exist even among those who are not seeking virtue. Is this not the case?

St. Aelred: As a consequence of their human nature, all men feel the need for friendship. For this reason, some similarity in feeling can generate a relationship that is not, however, a true and judicious friendship - which is spiritual. If we were to permit the name of friendship to this relation, we would have a kind of friendship we term carnal.

Carnal friendship springs from mutual harmony in vice. In a carnal friendship, a man wants another person to enjoy the pleasures of the body or senses. For example, a woman captivates a man, one is inflamed by the other, and they are kindled to form a sinful bond. Then, after they enter that “deplorable pact:” the one will do or suffer any crime or sacrilege for the sake of the other. And this is what they consider love and friendship.

They care nothing for uprightness or morals. The violence of their emotions and affections is what carries them away. How easily such passion can consume itself in its fury, or be dissolved with the same levity that fashioned it.

This is not true friendship, because when we indulge in sin we hate not only our own souls but also those we involve in sin. (5)


Worldly and spiritual friendship

Jan: Worldly friendships are very common today. Do they not have something true about them?

St. Aelred: Worldly friendship is also different from true friendship. It is born of a desire for temporal advantages or possessions, and is always full of deceit and intrigue. It contains nothing certain, nothing constant, nothing secure, for it changes with fortune and follows the purse. Here is the fair weather friend who disappears in the day of your trouble. Take away the hope of profit, and he ceases to be a friend. Such friendship in fact offends charity because one person pretends a love for another when really what he wants is the other’s goods.

Still, at times this vicious friendship can lead to a certain degree of true friendship. Those who first enter into an accord in the hope of common profit can reach a certain degree of pleasing mutual agreement and affection, in so far as human affairs are concerned. But a friendship should in no way be called true when it is begun and preserved for the sake of some temporal advantage. (6)


Jan: There are some who think they ought to love their friends contrary to faith and honor. Others say one should lie for a friend, or even submit himself to what is dishonorable and vile for the sake of friendship. Are these positions rights? Are there limits to friendship?

St. Aelred: It has been said that there are no limits to love as long as it remains true by observing the law of God.

Therefore, one ought not listen to those who say that one should act in behalf of a friend in a way detrimental to faith and uprightness (Gen 3:6). No one can sin for the sake of a friend: this is never an excuse for sin. It is impossible to prefer a friend to morality. As soon as morality is damaged, friendship vanishes.

Further, if anything foul or shameful is demanded of a friend and an affection still remains, it is a dishonorable sentiment unworthy of the name of friendship. (7)

Finally, consider that Christ himself set up a definite limit for friendship when he said: Greater love than this no man hath, that a man lay down his life for his friends (Jn 15:15). Now, since the life of the soul is of far greater excellence than that of the body, no one should do anything to a friend that would bring about the death of the soul. (8)

That is, we cannot accept in a friend either sin or a false creed – since both separate the soul from God and the soul from eternal life.


Principles that do not change

St. Aelred’s principles on a true friendship – which he calls spiritual friendship because the true friend is concerned more about the soul than the body of the person he cares for – are timeless. They can be applied to all times and places. Therefore, the modern world should bend to them, which is what Church teaching did until the foul winds of Vatican II blew in, bringing with them adaptation to the modern world.

Before, Catholics were always taught that there was no salvation outside the Catholic Church. Therefore it behooved them to do everything possible to bring the ones they loved into the one fold of Christ, rather than accommodate their errors for the sake of 'love' or 'friendship.' This is not a true charity or friendship.

The fountain and source of friendship is love of neighbor. And the solid foundation for this love is the love of God and the Catholic Church. Whatever is built on that foundation must conform to it and then it will last forever. This is, according to St. Alfred, the simple formula for true friendship.

The Saint has much more to say about friendship. He describes how a friend should first to be selected, next tested, finally admitted, and from then on treated as a friend deserves. Perhaps another time we can discuss those four stages.


1. Aelred of Rievaulx, De Spirituali Amicitia, or Spiritual Friendship, trans. By Mary E. Laker, Spiritual Friendship (Kalamazoo, MI: Cistercian Publications, 1977).
2. Ibid., This answer is based on replies of Abbot Aelred on pp. 52-55
3. Ibid., pp. 58-59
4. Ibid., p. 84
5. Ibid., pp. 58-59
6. Ibid. pp. 60-61
7. Ibid., pp. 79-80
8.Ibid., p. 87

Print this item

  Life of St. Cecilia by Dom Prosper Guéranger
Posted by: Stone - 11-18-2026, 08:08 PM - Forum: The Saints - Replies (11)

Life of St. Cecilia by Dom Prosper Guéranger
Taken from here.



Life of Saint Cecilia, Virgin and Martyr
By the Reverend Prosper Guéranger, Abbé de Solesmes.
Translated from the French.
> Cantantibus organis, Cæcilia Domino decantabat dicens: Fiat cor meum immaculatum ut non confundar. — Officium S. Cæciliæ, V. et M.
Philadelphia: Peter F. Cunningham, Catholic Bookseller, 216 South Third Street. 1866.
Permissu Superiorum.

Entered according to Act of Congress in the year 1866, by Peter F. Cunningham, in the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the United States, in and for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Stereotyped by Theodore Brown, 605 Sansom Street, Philadelphia.

Preface

In offering to the American public, a translation of the life of St. Cecilia, by the learned and laborious Dom Prosper Guéranger, the publisher feels assured he has made a valuable addition to our too narrow circle of Catholic literature.

The Church offers, in every age, in her Saints, Apostles, and Martyrs, brilliant examples of virtue, zeal, and heroic courage. While all are holy, there are still some, whose lives present features, at once so touching and sublime, that time can detract nothing from the interest which attaches to their names in every Catholic heart. Pre-eminent among these, is St. Cecilia, the gentle queen of Sacred Song, distinguished alike for her attachment to holy Virginity, her apostolic zeal, and the unfaltering courage by which she won the martyr's crown.

The author has followed with fidelity, the ancient Acts of St. Cecilia, the authenticity of which the reader will find satisfactorily defended in his pages. For less important details, he has claimed the right generally accorded to historians, of receiving probable evidence, where certain proofs cannot be obtained. On such authority, he has, for example, assumed with the learned Bosio and others, that the virtues of our Saint formed the crowning glory of the illustrious family of Cecilia Metella. The recital does not terminate with the death of Cecilia. The discoveries of her tomb, in the ninth and sixteenth centuries, form not the least interesting portion of the work. The description of the church which was once her dwelling, and the witness of her sufferings and triumphs, brings those scenes so vividly before us, that Cecilia seems to belong, as all the Saints of God most truly do, as much to our own day, as to the period when she still combated on earth.

We will not speak of the pleasure and instruction the author has afforded by his faithful pictures of the celebrated Ways of Ancient Rome, and the sacred cities of the dead, concealed in the holy shades beneath. For this, and much other interesting information, we refer the reader to the following pages, content, if, by our own humble labors, we have contributed to the edification of our Catholic brethren, and to the glory of Him who is admirable in His Saints.

The American Publisher.

Print this item

  Fr. Hewko: Work of St. Joseph (10 min. Devotion)  November 18 2026
Posted by: Deus Vult - 11-18-2026, 05:30 PM - Forum: November 2026 - No Replies

Work of St. Joseph (10 min. Devotion)
 November 18 2026 (NH)

Print this item

  Fr. Murr recounts long battle to expose Freemasonry within Vatican
Posted by: Stone - 11-17-2026, 12:02 PM - Forum: Resources Online - No Replies

Fr. Murr recounts long battle to expose Freemasonry within Vatican
Fr. Charles Murr explained at the Rome Life Forum how documentation was presented to Paul VI
that an archbishop who was also a Freemason 'was creating our new Mass and our new sacraments.'

[Emphasis - The Catacombs]

[Image: shutterstock_2444571935.jpg]

St. Peter's Basilica
Shutterstock

Nov 13, 2026
FATIMA, Portugal (LifeSiteNews) — Father Charles Murr discussed during this week’s 2026 Rome Life Forum the extensive Freemasonic infiltration of the Vatican as he witnessed it unfolding in the 1970s, the subject of his best-selling book Murder in the 33rd Degree: The Gagnon Investigation into Vatican Freemasonry.

During his talk, Murr recounted how, in 1974, while studying in Rome as a lay student, he met and befriended then-Archbishop Édouard Gagnon. Around the end of that same year, the priest explained that an unknown priest gave Cardinal Dino Staffa, the prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura, documents showing that Archbishop Annibale Bugnini was a member of an Italian Masonic lodge that would be substantiated and how it set off a chain of events leading to Gagnon investigating the entire Roman Curia for ties to Freemasonry.

Quote:“The priest came to him with documentation, according to the priest, proof of Annibale Bugnini … being a member of the Masonic Lodge of Italy … and he brought him documentation of that,” Murr said. “And very prudently he got in touch immediately with the Interpol and asked them to do an official investigation of the evidence, of these documents (to find out) were they in fact legitimate.”

WATCH: Masonic infiltration of Vatican exposed by Fr. Murr in viral video

“They came back saying, ‘Yes, they were legitimate.’ (Staffa) and Cardinal (Silvio) Oddi, of the congregation for bishops … went to go see Pope Paul VI with that documentation and they gave it to the Holy Father and said … well, I mean, what do they have to say, ‘We have a Freemason creating our new Mass and our new sacraments?’ Because that’s what it came down to,” he added.

Murr continued:
Quote:The pope did his own investigation; he called in (Cardinal) Giovanni Benelli, who was his sub-secretary of state … and Benelli said to the pope … ‘There should be an investigation of the entire Roman Curia, not just of Bugnini.’ Because if there’s one spot of cancer on the lung, you want to check the whole lung; as a matter of fact, you might even go through to the whole body and see if there’s anything else. The Holy Father agreed, and he asked, Benelli, ‘Who shall we send?’ … And (Benelli) said, ‘There is a French Canadian rector of the Pontifical Canadian College, (Archbishop) Édouard Gagnon,’ who happen(ed) to be a very wise man, a very good man, a saintly man … The pope commissioned him, and he agreed to the commission, and he set off to do an investigation of the Roman Curia.

To purchase a replay of the 2026 Rome Life Forum livestream and get access to Fr. Murr’s full talk, click here.

Print this item

  Msgr. Fenton: The Catholic Church and Salvation
Posted by: Stone - 11-17-2026, 11:54 AM - Forum: Articles by Catholic authors - Replies (1)

The Catholic Church and Salvation
Taken from here.

[Image: ?u=https%3A%2F%2Fimages-na.ssl-images-am...ipo=images]


All Catholics know and believe what was defined at the Lateran Council IV in 1215, namely that, “One indeed is the universal Church of the faithful, outside of which no one at all is saved.” We must believe that there is baptism of water, and the desire for that baptism, plus baptism of blood. We are greatly indebted to Monsignor Joseph Fenton for proper terminology to explain this dogma of the faith.

In his wonderful book entitled, “The Catholic Church and Salvation,” Msgr. Fenton analyzes “Suprema Haec Sacra,” a letter from the Holy Office issued on August 8, 1949 to Archbishop Cushing of Boston in response to the problem at St. Benedict Center at Cambridge. There, baptism of water alone was accepted as being within the Catholic Church.

Here is a thumbnail sketch of the document “Suprema haec sacra:”

1. The teaching that there is no salvation outside the Catholic Church is a dogma of the Catholic faith.

2. This dogma has always been taught, and will always be taught, infallibly by the Church’s magisterium.

3. The dogma must be understood and explained as the Church’s magisterium understands and explains it.

4. The Church is necessary for salvation with both a necessity of precept and a necessity of means.

5. Because the Church is necessary for salvation with the necessity of precept, any person who knows the Church to have been divinely instituted by Our Lord and yet refuses to enter it or to remain within it cannot attain eternal salvation.

6. The Church is a general and necessary means for salvation, not by reason of any intrinsic necessity, but only by God’s own institution, that is, because God in His merciful wisdom has established it as such.

7. In order that a man may be saved “within” the Church, it is not always necessary that he belong to the Church, actually as a member, but it can sometimes be enough that he belong to it as one who desires or wills to be in it. In other words, it is possible for one who belongs to the Church only in desire to be saved.

8. It is possible for this desire of entering the Church to be effective, not only when it is explicit, but also (when the person is invincibly ignorant of the true Church) even when that desire is merely implicit.

9. The Mystici Corporis reproved both the error of those who teach the impossibility of salvation for those who have only an implicit desire of entering the Church, and the false doctrine of those who claim that men may find salvation equally in every religion.

10. No desire to enter the Church can be effective for salvation unless it is enlightened by supernatural faith and animated or motivated by perfect charity.


“Within” or “Outside” the Church

Let us consider number (7) above. Here Father Fenton give us the word “within.” The dogma of faith says, “Outside the Church there is no salvation.” Here we have two important words as wonderful tools to work with. They are, “within” and “outside” the Catholic Church.

In his most important encyclical, Mystici Corporis Christi, Pope Pius XII defined what membership in the Church meant. It means that one is baptized with water, has the true faith, is subject to the true Pope and is not excommunicated. Here, the key word is “member.” A member, of course, is “within” the Church.

Now we have two more steps to make. One can be “within” the Church as a member and by true desire. Next we consider two important words of number (8) above, namely, “explicit” desire and “implicit” desire. Both these conditions of soul put one “within” the Catholic Church. In such a state of soul, one can receive forgiveness of sin and receive sanctifying grace.


“Explicit” and “Implicit” Desire to Enter the Church

We shall explain what “explicit” desire means. When a catechumen knows about the Church, about baptism and the like, he then has the choice to desire to enter the Church by baptism of water or not. If he turns with the help of grace to God and His Church in such a desire, he is then “within” the Church, with what we call an “explicit” act of desire. With that desire in his heart, he can make an act of perfect contrition. The result would be that he is freed from his sins, and he receives sanctifying grace. In that state he is ready for heaven.

Next, we explain the term “implicit” as it is found in number (8) above. Note that the term is modified by the word merely. Many thought that “implicit” desire to enter the Church was not enough. Let us explain the meaning of “implicit” desire to enter the Church. It means that a person who knows and believes explicitly the four things necessary for salvation is already in a state of soul which is pleasing to God. Let us say that the person is taken away after that instruction to a prison camp. There, no one will give him any more instruction. However, he desires the instruction with all his heart. Hence, his ignorance of the other truths of the faith is an invincible ignorance. He sincerely wants the knowledge and the reality Christ’s true Church has for him. With that desire and with the movement of actual grace that man or woman can make an act of perfect contrition. The effect of that act of perfect contrition will be that he or she will receive forgiveness of sins and also sanctifying grace. Again, in that state one is ready for the everlasting joys of heaven.


Four Things Necessary for Salvation

Lest some persons reading this be confused about the four things necessary for salvation, I shall say what they are in just four words:

1. Creator
2. Remunerator
3. Trinity
4. Savior

Without faith, it is impossible to please God (Hebrews), so he must have supernatural knowledge and faith in God the Creator who rewards the good and punishes the evil. That is absolutely necessary. Then we must always follow in the new dispensation (New Testament) that one must also believe in the Blessed Trinity and in the Savior, Our Lord Jesus Christ. After that explicit faith, where there is invincible ignorance, one can have merely “implicit” knowledge and faith as explained above.


Efficacious Desire to Enter the Church

We must consider another very important factor. The desire, whether it is explicit or merely implicit, must be truly efficacious. Let us take a simple example of an efficacious desire. A person desires to go to Australia. He gets a passport, a visa, a ticket, a flight reservation, and so forth. Even though he is not yet in Australia, he has an efficacious desire to get there, known by all the preparations.

Another person with an in-efficacious desire is a person who merely wants to go to Australia, but he does nothing about it at all. He has the money, and he has the time, but he does nothing about getting ready.

Now apply this to people in the world in regard to our holy religion, the Catholic Church. Many, yes very many desire to be in the true Church that Christ founded. However, not all of them have an efficacious desire, and unless the desire is efficacious, the act of contrition will not effect forgiveness of sins and the obtaining of sanctifying grace. Once again, “Outside the Church there is no salvation,” no forgiveness of sin, and there will be no obtaining of sanctifying grace.


A Caution from Pope Pius IX

We have another caution to give, and it is not mine but it is from Pope Pius IX. In “The Sources of Catholic Dogma” by Denzinger, we read some very sharp words from that holy pontiff. In number 1647, the pope chides those who go too deeply into the practical order. Who has that desire? What are the hidden workings of grace? The last words of that paragraph are, “it is unlawful to proceed further in inquiry.” Pope Pius IX then goes on to tell us to work and pray that all men may come to the knowledge of the true Church and lovingly join that true Church.


The Age of Reason - Decision Time

I urge those who have Fr. Fenton’s wonderful book to read it and re-read it. On pages 71 - 72, we find a wonderful study on un-baptized persons coming to the age of reason. When such a person reaches the age of reason, he must make a decision to enter the divine order (the kingdom of Heaven) or to go contrary to the kingdom of Heaven, namely to enter the kingdom of Satan. As stated above, his efficacious desire takes away original sin and gives him sanctifying grace. The opposite desire (rebellion) puts into his soul his first mortal sin.


Work and Pray for All Mankind

While we thank God for our faith and presence “within” the Church, we must work and pray that all men may find and live “within” the one ark of salvation, the Holy Roman Catholic Church.

Print this item

  Leo XIV vows to maintain Pope Francis’ restrictions on Latin Mass
Posted by: Stone - 11-17-2026, 11:48 AM - Forum: Pope Leo XIV - No Replies

Leo XIV vows to maintain Pope Francis’ restrictions on Latin Mass
Asked whether he might revoke Francis’ 2021 restrictions, Leo said, ‘Not right now,’ 
adding that most Catholics ‘celebrate the rite of Vatican II, of Paul VI,’ and ‘will continue to do that.’

[Image: Untitled-19.png]

Pope Leo XIV
OSCAR GONZALEZ FUENTES/Shutterstock

Nov 17, 2026
ABOARD THE PAPAL PLANE (LifeSiteNews) — Pope Leo XIV declared that he will continue enforcing Pope Francis’s Traditionis Custodes restrictions on the Latin Mass in the name of Church unity.

On November 17, during an in-flight press conference while returning to Rome from his apostolic journey to South America, Pope Leo confirmed that his administration will maintain Pope Francis’s 2021 motu proprio restricting the Traditional Latin Mass while affirming that the vast majority of Catholics will continue celebrating the Novus Ordo Missae of Paul VI.

In response to a Le Figaro correspondent who asked the Pope whether he was considering the possibility of moving beyond or revoking Traditionis Custodes, Leo replied: “Not right now. Traditions Custodes is the decision of Francis, and we will continue to follow it.”

“Traditionis Custodes includes the possibility of dispensation, allowing the Vetus Ordo Mass to be celebrated,” the Pope continued.

Justifying the ongoing restrictions, the Pope insisted that liturgical uniformity under the post-conciliar rite remains essential for ecclesiastical unity. “For the unity of the Church,” the Pope highlighted, “the vast majority of Catholics around the world celebrate the rite of Vatican II, of Paul VI, and we will continue to do that.” He added: “There is an avenue available for those who wish to apply for the dispensation.”

By framing adherence to the post-conciliar liturgy as a matter of “unity,” Pope Leo XIV reinforces the rhetoric utilized during the previous pontificate to marginalize traditionalist communities.

His remarks aboard the papal plane follow a two-week tour of South America – covering Uruguay, Argentina, and Peru – during which the Pontiff repeatedly promoted the unity of the “synodal Church” and called for structural continuity with the agenda of Pope Francis.

In 2007, Pope Benedict XVI issued the landmark motu proprio Summorum Pontificum, acknowledging that the Traditional Latin Mass had never been abrogated and affirming every Latin-rite priest the freedom to celebrate it without asking for permission from their bishop. Benedict’s decree led to a massive resurgence of vocations for traditionalist communities, youth engagement, and thriving parish communities across the globe.

However, in July 2021, Pope Francis overturned Benedict XVI’s reconciliation efforts by issuing Traditionis Custodes. Francis declared the Novus Ordo to be the “unique expression of the Roman Rite,” restricted the establishment of new traditionalist groups, and required priests to obtain explicit diocesan and Vatican authorization to offer the ancient Mass.

Following the election of Pope Leo XIV in May 2025, many traditionalist Catholics harbored hopes that the new Pontiff might grant a liturgical truce or restore canonical protection to traditionalist groups in the Church. However, Leo XIV’s latest declarations aboard the papal plane extinguish those expectations, confirming unbroken continuity with post-conciliar liturgical policies.

Print this item

  Commentaries on the Bible — Cornelius a Lapide - PDF
Posted by: Stone - 11-16-2026, 08:43 PM - Forum: Resources Online - No Replies

Print this item

  Quo Primum is a forever binding document
Posted by: Sheshallcrush - 11-15-2026, 10:47 PM - Forum: In Defense of Tradition - No Replies

The true Mass and the eternally binding document Quo Primum

Disclaimer: This post is my personal opinion and you must do your own research to verify the information contained within this post.

Imagine a Catholic who had spent his entire life going to a traditional Latin Mass.
Then, within a few years after Vatican 2, the sanctuary was rearranged. The priest would face the people. Latin would disappear. Gregorian chant disappears. The old altar was removed or relegated to the side. The priest might speak conversationally and no longer reverently. Lay people might come forward for various liturgical functions. Hymns that sounded more like popular music could replace traditional sacred music. The atmosphere of silence could be replaced by constant verbal interaction. The priest says the sacred canon in a loud voice. 
And then, in some parishes, things became considerably worse.


There were liturgical experiments involving folk music, guitars, drums, dancing, theatrical presentations, informal vesture, unusual offertory practices, balloons, children's performances, and other gimmicks. The term “clown Mass” became associated with the Novus Ordo. Many Catholics would leave the church or not go to Mass anymore. Husbands and fathers would no longer want to lead their families to Mass when there is zero reverence and a complete lack of masculinity from the priest. 


There is the false notion many Catholics have that the New Order Mass is just a simple translation of the traditional Latin rite, with a few small changes here and there. This is not true. It is a re-write, and quite substantial one, undertaken by a commission set up by Paul VI to implement the Council’s teaching on the liturgy. 

The head of this commission was a man named Archbishop Anibale Bugnini. This man was suspect  to being a freemason. Many modernists in the Vatican knew this all along but once word got out, they were forced to exile Bugnini to Iran. So essentially the main architect of the Novus Ordo mass was a Freemason thus making it a modernist-Masonic ceremony. Bugnini also brought six Protestant “experts” to the commission in order to help design the new mass. These “experts” would destroy the ancient Roman Rite given to us by St. Peter and safeguarded by St. Pope Clement in 88 AD. By the time of Pope Gregory the Great the canon of the Mass and prayers were fixed. From that moment it was basically unchanged for nearly 1,400 years until Vatican 2. The traditional worship handed down by Our Lord and His apostles was replaced with a new Protestant-Masonic style worship called the Novus Ordo.


Eugene Brand, one of the Lutheran representatives at this commission, later publicly boasted, “We have finished the work that Martin Luther began.” And Fr. Bugnini stated that his aim in designing the New Mass was “to strip from our Catholic prayers and from the Catholic liturgy everything which can be the shadow of a stumbling block for our separated brethren, that is, for the Protestants.” 

Jean Guiton, an observer at Vatican 2 stated, “The goal of Paul VI was to make the Catholic Mass look closer to a Calvinist mass.” 

Why are we making the mass more appealing to Protestants? Why are we inviting Protestant “experts” to give us advice on how to run our Mass? Why are we destroying a 2000 year old ancient Latin rite?

The designers of the New Mass have boasted endlessly on the novelty and revolutionary nature of their creation, and you can find many examples. I will give one here: Fr. Joseph Gelineau, SJ, one of the Catholic “experts” involved in its formulation, stated: “This needs to be said without ambiguity: the Roman Rite as we knew it no longer exists. It has been destroyed." 

Modernist Paul VI stated: 
“The introduction of the vernacular will certainly be a great sacrifice for those who know the beauty, the power and the expressive sacrality of Latin. We are parting with the speech of the Christian centuries, we are becoming like profane intruders in the literary preserve of sacred utterance. We will lose a great part of that stupendous and incomparable artistic and spiritual thing, Gregorian chant.” -Pope Paul VI

Compare this with St. Pope Pius X: “The language proper to the Roman church is Latin. Hence it is forbidden to sing anything whatever in the vernacular in solemn liturgical functions-much more to sing in the vernacular the variable or common parts of the mass and office.” 

And Pope Pius XII:

“The day the Church abandons her universal tongue [Latin] is the day before she returns to the catacombs." -Pope Pius XII


The Council of Trent says that it is forbidden to create a new experimental rite for the Roman Church:

"If anyone says that the received and approved rites of the Catholic Church... may be changed by any pastor of the Churches whomsoever to any new ones: let him be anathema."
[Canon 13 on the Sacraments, Session VII, March 3, 1547]

St. Pope Pius V canonized the Latin Mass in his binding document Quo Primum: 

“Let all everywhere adopt and observe what has been handed down by the Holy Roman Church, the Mother and Teacher of the other churches, and let Masses not be sung or read according to any other formula than that of this Missal published by us.” Quo Primum, St. Pope Pius V

“Would anyone, however, presume to commit such an act [infringe on this decree], he should know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul.” -Quo Primum, St. Pope Pius V

Canon lawyer and doctor in Thomistic theology Fr Hesse explains why Quo Primum is a forever binding document. 
“The law that has to be prayed (lex orandi) determines the law that has to be believed (lex credendi). For example, in early times of Christianity the immaculate conception was the law that had to be prayed. There was even a specific day set during the year to venerate Mary and the immaculate conception; but, it was not the law that had to be believed until Pope Pius IX defined it in the 19th century. Now no Pope can ever take this back. It is forever binding. The Tridentine Mass was the law that had to be prayed, codified by the council of Trent. After the council of Trent, Saint Pope Pius V created a papal bull called Quo Primum in which he defined that the Tridentine Mass was the law that had to be believed. Therefore, the Tridentine Mass is the official Mass of the Roman Church and no one can ever change this. This is forever binding and no Pope can change this.”


The argument is that the Mass should not be understood as merely a disciplinary regulation that a pope may freely redesign according to changing pastoral preferences, but as the Church’s lex orandi—the law of prayer through which the faith itself is expressed and handed down. In this view, the principle lex orandi, lex credendi means that what the Church worships publicly is intimately connected to what she believes doctrinally: the liturgy is therefore not simply a set of external rules but is the core expression of the Catholic faith. This is the reasoning behind the claim that Quo Primum carried a significance extending beyond ordinary liturgical legislation. When St. Pius V promulgated the Roman Missal in 1570, he sought to establish a unified Roman rite and used exceptionally strong language concerning its perpetual use. The popes who followed him did not treat this as an ordinary or disciplinary law that could simply be discarded at will. Instead, subsequent popes made revisions within the Roman Missal rather than repudiating its fundamental form: they added saints' feasts, adjusted calendars, clarified rubrics, and made limited modifications while retaining the essential structure and the Roman Canon. Even when genuine changes were made, they were presented as revisions of the received Roman Missal rather than the creation of an entirely new liturgical system. 


Some “conservatives” from the Novus Ordo argue that St. Pope Pius V never intended to bind his successors because he edited the Missal right after he published it. This is a faulty argument. St. Pope Pius V never actually changed the Missal, he simply clarified some things that were unclear. The 1570 Missal was the initial edition, and there were multiple printings almost immediately afterward. The early printings contained typographical and textual corrections. The first edition itself had some corrections made during printing, and further corrections appeared in the 1571 printings. Pius V added the feast of Our Lady of Victory in 1571, following the Christian victory at Lepanto. His successor Gregory XIII subsequently changed the name of that feast to the Feast of the Most Holy Rosary. We clearly see that fixing typographical errors or adding feast days for saints does not contradict Quo Primum. Changing the essential structure of the mass to be something entirely different is what contradicts Quo Primum. From the Council of Trent to 1962 no Pope ever dared to change or alter the Roman Missal. When Popes after Pius V would make revisions to add feast days they would always add their name after Pius V in the missal. They kept the name of Pius V because they wanted to make clear that they are respecting Quo Primum and are working within it. Keeping the name of Pius V is unusual because normally Popes cancel out their predecessors' names when they make a revision. Clearly the Popes have understood Quo Primum to be binding on them. John XXIII and Paul VI were the first that dared to go against Quo Primum. The Tridentine Mass is the only Mass of the Roman Catholic Church.


Father David Hewko states: 

“The Mass codified by St. Pope Pius V is like a perfectly cut diamond. One more cut or modification will ruin the whole thing. This is why Saint Pius V made the Tridentine Mass the true Mass to last until the end of time.” (Sermon August 2020 SSPX Marian Corps)


The traditionalist argument reaches its strongest point when contrasted with the reform promulgated by Paul VI. His own apostolic constitution explicitly acknowledges that the reform involved a revision of the Ordo Missae, a substantially enlarged lectionary, changes to the rites of the Mass, and, most significantly, the addition of three new Eucharistic Prayers alongside the Roman Canon. It also states that portions of the offertory, the breaking of the bread, and Communion rites were simplified or altered. From this perspective, the concern is theological as much as disciplinary: if the traditional Roman Mass had served for centuries as the Church's authoritative expression of Eucharistic sacrifice, priesthood, worship, and Catholic belief, then substantially replacing its prayers and ritual structure necessarily raises the question of whether something more profound than a disciplinary adjustment has occurred. The case, therefore, is that the Mass is not merely a rulebook for how Catholics happen to worship; it is one of the principal ways the Catholic faith is confessed, transmitted, and embodied.


During the promulgation of the new mass, traditionalist Cardinal Ottaviani and Bacci wrote a critical study of the new mass. They were helped by theologians Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and Bishop De Laurier. This was called the Ottaviani intervention. Here is what they said:

“…the Novus Ordo represents, both as a whole and in its details, a striking departure from the Catholic theology of the Mass as it was formulated in Session XXIII of the Council of Trent...It is evident that the Novus Ordo has no intention of presenting the Faith as taught by the Council of Trent, to which, nonetheless, the Catholic conscience is bound forever…” -Ottaviani Intervention (A study of the Novus Ordo mass)

Vatican 2 is similar to the heretical council of Pistoia condemned by Pope Pius VI (not to be confused with Paul VI). This was a council created by bishops who had modernist and Jansenist beliefs. Pope Pius VI condemned its teachings in Auctorem fidei (1794 AD), judging 85 propositions from the synod to be erroneous, heretical, schismatic, or otherwise dangerous because they undermined established Catholic doctrine and, particularly, the the Church's received tradition and liturgy. 


Pope Pius VI 1794 AD exposes the clever strategy these innovators use to introduce error and heresy: Ambiguities.

"They knew the capacity of innovators in the art of deception. In order not to shock the ears of Catholics, the innovators sought to hide the subtleties (errors) of their tortuous maneuvers by the use of seemingly innocuous words (ambiguities) such as would allow them to insinuate error into souls in the most gentle manner. Once the truth had been compromised, they could, by means of slight changes or additions in phraseology, distort the confession of the faith (the doctrine) that is necessary for our salvation, and lead the faithful by subtle errors to their eternal damnation…” -Pope Pius VI’s Apostolic Constitution Auctorem Fidei against the Errors of the Synod of Pistoia- August, 28,1794

Compare this with the Vatican 2 innovators: 


"We have used ambiguous terms during the Council and we know how we shall interpret them afterwards." -Fr. Edward Schillebeeckx, consultant at the Second Vatican “Council”


“The Church has peacefully undergone its October Revolution” Fr. Yves Congar, referring to Vatican II

Further, Pope Pius VI when he condemned the heretical council of Pistoia, also condemned the new mass 175 years before it was created.

33. “The proposition of the synod by which it shows itself eager to remove the cause through which, in part, there has been induced a forget-fulness of the principles relating to the order of the liturgy, "by recalling it (the liturgy) to a greater simplicity of rites, by expressing it in the vernacular language, by uttering it in a loud voice" as if the present order of the liturgy, received and approved by the Church, had emanated in some part from the forgetfulness of the principles by which it should be regulated…” Pope Pius VI calls this: “RASH, OFFENSIVE TO PIOUS EARS, INSULTING TO THE CHURCH, FAVORABLE TO THE CHARGES OF HERETICS AGAINST IT.”


Here is a snap shot of the changes to the Novus Ordo Mass: 

  1. The prayers at the foot of the altar and ancient offertory prayers have been replaced by downplaying sacrificial language. They now resemble a Jewish table blessing.
  2. The last gospel was removed.
  3. The universal Language Latin was taken away and vernacular introduced.
  4. Communion in the hand leading to careless abuses.
  5. Communion under both bread and wine instead of bread alone. This makes people see it as a symbol instead of the true transubstantiation taking place with flesh and blood in the host.
  6. Female altar-servers serving at the altar during Mass with the priest.
  7. Lay people handing out communion even though their hands are not anointed.
  8. 16 genuflections reduced down to only 3.
  9. More focus on scripture readings and reduction of ritual gives a protestantized tone.
  10. Priest facing the people instead of God at the altar implies man is the priority and not God.
  11. Altars removed and replaced with a table for a communal meal similar to Protestant churches.
  12. Communion rails torn out because no need to kneel for Blessed Sacrament anymore.


If St. Robert Bellarmine were alive today he would condemn the new Mass: 
St. Robert Bellarmine said:  "When we enter ornate and clean Basilicas, adorned with crosses, sacred images, altars and burning lamps, we most easily conceive devotion.  But on the other hand, when we enter the temples of the heretics, where there is nothing except a chair for preaching and a table for making a meal, we feel ourselves to be entering a profane hall and not the House of God."

Print this item