The Catholic Trumpet [Video]: SSPX - Hermeneutered by Dialogue

[Stone]

Hermeneutered by Dialogue: The Neo-SSPX Continues Its Tango with the Conciliar Church

Dear Resistance,

If what was good yesterday is good today, and what was evil yesterday is still evil today, Catholics are forced to ask a simple, unavoidable question.
That question is addressed directly and without compromise in the newest video released on The Catholic Trumpet YouTube channel.

In 1991, Bernard Tissier de Mallerais and Richard Williamson of the SSPX consecrated Licínio Rangel in Brazil — without negotiations, without agreements, without recognition, without appeasement of the Conciliar Church. That act was defended as necessary and Catholic.

Today, in 2026, we see Father Pagliarani and the Neo-SSPX leadership meeting with Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, architect of documents that undermine Our Lady’s role as Co-Redemptrix and Mediatrix of all Graces.

That is not resistance. That is collaboration.

History has already shown the pattern.

Within one year of his consecration, Bishop Rangel reconciled with Rome and accepted the Novus Ordo. Bishop Rifan followed: acceptance of the New Mass, altar girls, and Vatican II in practice.

The lesson is devastating: valid episcopal consecrations do not preserve the Faith when doctrine is surrendered.

We do not lack bishops. We lack faith and doctrinal fidelity.

This trajectory did not begin yesterday. The GREC meetings of 1994–1995 initiated structured dialogue with Modernist Rome — engagement without condemnation, discussion without clarity — a Hegelian tango now spanning more than three decades.

The rupture became formal in 2012 with the Doctrinal Declaration and General Chapter, abandoning Archbishop Lefebvre’s principle of “no practical agreement without a prior doctrinal agreement.”

Everything since has been damage control — not reversal.

Until the Neo-SSPX:

• Condemns the GREC trajectory

• Rejects the 2012 Doctrinal Declaration

• Repudiates Ecclesia Dei and Cardinal Hoyos’ conditions

• Purges conciliar sacramental dependency

• Openly condemns Vatican II as Marcel Lefebvre did …new consecrations are merely spectacle.

+Archbishop Lefebvre ordered his Bishops to provide the sacraments, and to pass down and preach the Faith of Eternal Rome.

The question remains: Will we hold the Faith — or negotiate with its destroyers?

In the Sacred and Immaculate Hearts,

- The Catholic Trumpet

“Anyone who loves the Truth hates Error. This hatred of Error is the touchstone by which one recognizes love for the Truth. If you do not love the Truth, you may say, up to a certain point, that you love It and even believe It; but be sure that, in this case, you will lack a horror of that which is false, and by this sign you will recognize that you do not love the Truth. When a man who loves Truth ceases to love It, he does not begin by declaring his defection from It: he begins by detesting Error less.” -Ernest Hello, L’Homme